Sunday, 7 November 2010

Compare And Contrast


Contrasting colours in a border at Dalemain

We went to Cumbria for our holiday, which meant I got to visit two gardens I'd been wanting to see for a while now - Hutton-in-the-Forest, and Dalemain.

In some ways there were a lot of similarities between them ... the backdrop of the stately home, the formal areas, the topiary, the woodland, the flower beds spilling over onto gravel paths.


Click on photos to enlarge - the collages may be rather big if you don't have broadband

They seemed to me (and to R) to have a completely different atmosphere, however. Walking round Hutton-in-the-Forest, we felt as if there were no continuity, as though each area had grown up separately from the others and nothing had been done to link them together. Parts of it are beautiful, but it seemed to us to be very disjointed. This may be because different areas of garden have been added at different periods in the house's history - it's not a garden designed to be viewed as a whole (in fact it didn't seem to be a garden which had been designed as such at all) - but for us the effect was disappointing.

The topiary, for instance, all seemed rather haphazard, with clipped trees in mushroom shapes and balls in front of the house, hedges topped with a range of different curved features forming two sides of the "walled" garden, and a mix of huge egg shapes and sharply pointed pyramids within it.


Topiary at Hutton-in-the-Forest

The garden also seemed to be rather lacking in imagination. I had been keen to see the walled garden - and I did like its cottage-style flowerbeds - but I wasn't impressed by the number of straight lines everywhere, and big square lawns with urns positioned in their dead centres. Perhaps it's just because I don't like formal gardens much.


Hutton-in-the-Forest, walled garden

R had liked the sound of a garden surrounded by woodland, but we both thought that a lot more could have been done to make the garden flow into the woodland, to make it seem a part of the garden, rather than something which just happened to be in the background. The woodland itself was quite pretty, but nothing special - as far as we were concerned, we could have gone to some public woods and walked there for free.

I don't want to give the impression that Hutton isn't worth visiting - it was interesting to see it, though without our Gardeners' World Magazine two-for-one card we might have found it a bit expensive (especially as everything in the low garden had just been dug up and it was a sea of mud - I imagine it will be a bit more interesting when something has been done with this space). The flowers in the walled garden are lovely, and I rather fell for this gate:


Bluebell gate at Hutton-in-the-Forest

But our overall impression was one of disjointedness.

Dalemain, for all its superficial similarities, was a complete contrast, a lovely flowing garden which made us feel that we were moving naturally from one area to another. Although it was a mixture of formal and informal sections, they were very well integrated and the whole thing felt much more as though it had been deliberately designed to to fit together.


Knot garden at Dalemain

There were wide expanses of lawn, but the way their edges curved around with sweeping flower beds which both partially concealed and led into the next area made the garden much more interesting. There was topiary, but its symetrical shapes and leading lines gave much more of a sense that it had been designed to be part of the garden, rather than just plonked down at random in the middle of it.


Upper garden at Dalemain, with lawns and topiary

The upper garden, packed with plants and imagination, was linked with the lower, woodland garden by steps down to a shrub-lined path. The woodland garden was more like an arboretum than a public wood, and the different colours and textures of the foliage gave it more character.


Dalemain's low garden, leading to woodland area and riverside walk

Some aspects of Dalemain were slightly quirky - taken to an extreme this could have been irritating, but it was sufficiently subtle that it was actually a delight. The woodland garden concealed a sleeping giantess; one section of the upper garden contained a spiral of corn and wildflowers; and the labels in the children's border were handcrafted wooden animals which reflected the common names of the plants in this area. Clearly the garden is intended to be a fun place to visit as well as an interesting one.


Other animal labels included harebells, snapdragon, cranesbill - and solomon's seal!

The garden of Hutton-in-the-Forest felt as if it were there for show - primarily to provide views for visitors to the house. As I said, the disjointedness caused by none of the areas seeming to link together may be due to different sections having been added over the centuries, but the result was that it didn't give the impression of being owned by a gardener.

Dalemain, on the other hand, felt like a real plantsman's garden and a labour of love. Its character, imagination, and continuity impressed even R, who is totally uninterested in gardening - "can we buy this one?" he asked, his standard response when he falls for a garden.


Border at Dalemain

Sadly I don't think we could afford it, even if it were for sale, but we will certainly go back and visit again at the first opportunity.

7 comments:

VP said...

What a coincidence! Someone mentioned Dalemain to me on Saturday and I'd never heard heard of it. Now here you are actually taking us on a tour :)

It looks a fine garden and one that's on my list for the next time we visit Cumbria.

easygardener said...

It is true that some gardens just don't feel right - they have the right ingredients but they don't come together well as a whole. I have walked around gardens with a slight feeling of unease until I realise it is disappointment that I am actually feeling.

Juliet said...

VP - I hope you manage to get to see Dalemain for yourself some time. I gather the best time to go is probably late May/early June, as it's famous for its Meconopsis and Roses, but it was still lovely in September. There are also walks on the estate - and a very nice tea-room!

EG - I always walk round gardens with a very critical R who lets me know right away if he doesn't think they're up to scratch! Hutton turned out to be not his sort of garden anyway, but we both had the feeling that it could have been put together so much better.

Amazing said...

Juliet I have been to Dalemain. It was a couple of years ago. I must see if I have some photos.

Juliet said...

I look forward to seeing them if you do, Amazing :)

Anna said...

I enjoyed your post Juliet. Have visited Cumbria regularly over the years but have never visited either garden so will have to remedy that. I do like those animal plant labels.

Juliet said...

Thanks, Anna.

The labels are fun, aren't they? - they had a few for sale in the shop, but the only one they had there which is in my current garden was Leopard's Bane (Doronicum), and I'm not sure it's something I'll want in new garden, so I decided against getting one.