I have finally managed to finish my list - it's taken several days as I have so many other things to do at the moment. So, here it is - I'm tempted to say "in no particular order", but actually it's more or less in the order in which I read the books ...
A Little Princess - Frances Hodgson Burnett
This was my favourite book when I was 5 or 6 (when I exhausted my parents with endless games of pretending to be "Princess" Sara) and I still re-read it today. Unlike many modern princess stories, it has a real plot, and encourages children to use their imaginations. It's not a book about p*nk tutus and fairy wands; it's a book about retaining ones spirit in the face of cruel and unjust authorities, about the triumph of good over evil. It's also a lot better than the film, which over-sentimentalised it and changed the ending.
Watership Down - Richard Adams
I was given this for Christmas when I was 7 and it immediately became my new favourite book. Again, it quickly incorporated itself into my childhood games - all my dolls were rabbits! I read it so many times that I wore out three copies and am now on my fourth.
The Phantom Tollbooth - Norton Juster
Another childhood Christmas present which I couldn't put down. Full of clever conceits and wordplay, it still makes me laugh and it's one of the first books I'd turn to if I were stuck in bed or needed something to cheer me up.
The Tombs Of Atuan - Ursula Le Guin
I loved Le Guin's
Earthsea Trilogy as a child, and the second story in particular really spoke to me, perhaps because there's such a strong female character in it. It fostered my lifelong love of science fiction and fantasy, of reading about other worlds where magic is real and anything can happen, and it made me feel involved in a way no other book had done until then.
These Old Shades - Georgette Heyer
It's too easy to dismiss Heyer's books as sub-Austen or worse still, as chick-lit. They are neither. She might not be a writer of the same calibre as Austen, but then few authors are. She is a wonderful story-teller, and her books are as full of adventure and of well-researched historical details as they are of romance. I first discovered them at the age of about 10 or 11, my Mum and Dad both love them, and
These Old Shades is one of R's favourite books as well as one of mine.
My Family And Other Animals - Gerald Durrell
I don't think this was the first of Durrell's autobiographical stories I'd read when I was given it at school at the age of 11, and I'm not entirely sure whether it's really my favourite, but it's difficult to pick one among so many. His books are packed with amusing anecdotes and enjoyable to read, and this one about his childhood in Corfu in particular is a lot of fun. However, it's the serious issues he raises, about our destruction of various ecosystems - and thus of the species which rely on them - and of hunting animals to the point of extinction, which really spoke to me when I read his books. I've been a supporter of several conservation projects, including
the zoo Durrell founded, (not to display animals in an unnatural environment, but to protect and study them so they can be saved from extinction), ever since.
Lord Of The Rings - JRR Tolkein
I first read this when I was about 12 and I didn't notice either the minimal number of female characters or the lengthy descriptions for which Tolkein is often criticised. I just enjoyed the story! And I still do. I think the books are much better than the films, which spend far too much time focusing on the battle scenes at the expense of many important characters and plot developments.
The Chrysalids - John Wyndham
This was another book I was given to read at school and it really captured my imagination. The appeal was partly the post-apocalyptic future setting, which continued to foster my love of SF, but also partly because - as someone who was bullied at school - I identified strongly with the main characters, who are persecuted because they are different from everyone else. It was one of the first books I read which didn't have a conventional happy ending, and I still find the moral ambiguity thought-provoking.
The Daughter Of Time - Josephine Tey
I'm tempted to just write "Richard III is innocent!" and leave it at that. I can't remember when I first read this book, probably when I was in my teens, but it made a really big impression on me. I don't think I had realised before that much of what we view as history is a subjective interpretation of events rather than objective truth. It's only looking back at it now that I realise how important this has been to me: I have a passion for justice and also for finding out the truth, which is what good academic research is all about.
Gaudy Night - Dorothy L Sayers
The third of Sayers' Harriet Vane stories (if you haven't read them, start with
Strong Poison), I love this primarily because it's such a wonderful portrait of university life, but it's also a clever detective novel, a beautifully understated love story, and an examination of the way in which women of the period were too often forced to choose between a career and a family.
Emma - Jane Austen
I know the default novel to pick is
Pride And Prejudice, and yes, I like that too, but Emma is my favourite Austen heroine. The OED's
"which Jane Austen character are you?" quiz tells me I'm Elizabeth Bennet, and that's lovely, because everyone wants to be Lizzie, don't they? - but in real life I have to confess that I'm a control freak and I can't help identifying with Emma.
The Church Mouse - Graham Oakley
I was too old to read Graham Oakley's Church Mice books as a child, so I didn't discover them until I was a student, browsing bookshops, and then I really fell for both the stories and the clever illustrations. I still collect them, and I often re-read them too. If you know a child of about 5 who has outgrown basic picture books but isn't quite ready for story-books, then get hold of a copy of
The Church Mouse for them - but do make sure you get an original 1970s copy and not one of the 2009 reprints, which squashed the wonderfully detailed drawings into half the original size.
Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency - Douglas Adams
Controversially, I prefer this to the
Hitch-Hiker books. I love the literary jokes and the Cambridge references, but even if you know nothing about Coleridge, it also has an electric monk, an impossibly stuck sofa, a time-machine, and an anti-hero detective who believes in the fundamental interconnectedness of all things. What's not to like?!
No Bed For Bacon - Caryl Brahms and SJ Simon
This is the book which Tom Stoppard apparently didn't (deliberately) plagiarise for the plot of
Shakespeare In Love. I still think the estates of Brahms and Simon should be getting royalties from the film-makers though! Read it and see if you agree.
Angels And Men - Catherine Fox
I love this book, because it's funny, sexy, and intelligent, because Fox writes about issues of faith without feeling a need to hit you over the head with her own beliefs, and because it makes me feel nostalgic as it reminds me (just a little bit) of my own student days.
Harry Potter And The Philosopher's Stone - JK Rowling
I like all the Harry Potter stories, but the first one stands out for me, because Rowling's magical world is all so new, to the reader as well as to Harry. Well-written and funny, it's a great page-turner of a story in its own right as well as being full of clever details which will become significant in the later stories.
The Book Of Job
Before I got ME I'd probably have said my favourite book of the Bible was the
Psalms, but in the last few years I've realised how much I appreciate Job. I like it because Job keeps questioning and refuses to give in, because it compares our own experiences with the workings of the universe and puts them into perspective, and because it doesn't give any glib answers. Anyone who's ever been seriously ill will know that at some point, some well meaning person will come alongside you and tell you that the illness is your own fault, that you brought it on yourself, and that if only you do this, that, or the other, you will get well again. I don't think it's a spoiler to say that the book of Job explodes this point of view - his "friends" are proved wrong and he is vindicated! And finally, I like the fact that, even though this is, chronologically speaking, probably the oldest book in the Old Testament, Job's daughters are named and given equal inheritance with their brothers - one in the eye for those theologians who try to use Scriptures to justify their own mysogyny.
Stardust - Neil Gaiman
I've loved Neil Gaiman since the TV adaptation of
Neverwhere in the mid-nineties, and
Stardust is my favourite of his books: if I had to pick my top 5 books, it would probably be in that list too. A fairy story for adults, it's darker than the film and has a great deal more character and plot development - reading Gaiman's wonderfully lyrical writing, you really feel drawn into his magical world.
The Eyre Affair - Jasper Fforde
Fforde is another of my top 5 authors and I had difficulty choosing which of his novels to put on this list, having limited myself to one book per writer. I think
Shades Of Grey is his best book (I've written about this before,
here), but
The Eyre Affair is probably my personal favourite. It's set in an alternative universe where dodos have been cloned and are kept as pets, England is still fighting the Crimean War, Wales is a socialist republic, and literature has the status our own universe accords to rock music or football. It manages to combine a very silly sense of humour, original ideas, and a lot of literary allusions (if you haven't read it and are going to, it doesn't matter if you miss some of these, but you will at least need to be familiar with the plot of
Jane Eyre).
Un Lun Dun - China Mieville
Another unusual fantasy novel, this is aimed at teenagers who want something a bit less conventional than Harry Potter. Like Gaiman and Fforde as well as Rowling, Mieville has created another world which is both very different from our own and yet instantly recognisable, one which is so well-described you find yourself drawn into it and caring what happens to its peculiar assortment of characters. I love the way it slyly subverts JK Rowling's idea of the "chosen one" and encourages readers to make their own decisions and take charge of their own adventures.
So, that's my list - today, at any rate. Some of the choices were easy to make, but others were more difficult and I've a much longer list of books which had to be left out, so if I were to do this again another day my top 20 might be a little different. At the moment though, I'm just hoping that tomorrow I won't remember any really important books I've forgotten ...
For more favourite books, visit
VP's blog.